Skip to content

Instantly share code, notes, and snippets.

@IdelsTak
Created July 16, 2024 00:49
Show Gist options
  • Save IdelsTak/7fce0e197709736245d2c4e18b655f0c to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Save IdelsTak/7fce0e197709736245d2c4e18b655f0c to your computer and use it in GitHub Desktop.
Comparison of Gradle and Maven project types for building a Java application

NetBeans Project Types Overview

Gradle Project Types

  1. Java Application
    • Pros: Easy setup, benefits from Gradle's performance optimizations, suitable for simple projects.
    • Cons: Less manageable for large projects, limited structure.
  2. Java Class Library
    • Pros: Ideal for reusable libraries, modular development, efficient dependency management.
    • Cons: Not for standalone applications, requires integration.
  3. Web Application
    • Pros: Web-focused, dynamic UIs, scalable.
    • Cons: Complex setup, requires server infrastructure.
  4. Micronaut Project
    • Pros: Microservices-friendly, lightweight, fast, modern.
    • Cons: Higher complexity, requires framework knowledge.
  5. Multi-Project Build
    • Pros: Facilitates modular development, clear separation of concerns.
    • Cons: Complex setup, challenging dependency management.
  6. Java Frontend Application
    • Pros: Uses MVVM pattern, rich UIs with web technologies, cross-platform.
    • Cons: Steep learning curve, complex integration, potential performance overhead.

Maven Project Types

  1. Java Application
    • Pros: Simple, lightweight, good for small projects.
    • Cons: Not scalable for larger applications, manual dependency management.
  2. Web Application
    • Pros: Suitable for web applications, rich UI, scalable.
    • Cons: Complex, requires server resources, higher learning curve.
  3. Enterprise Application
    • Pros: Modular, scalable, easy integration with enterprise services.
    • Cons: Overhead for simple projects, complex setup, resource-intensive.
  4. FXML JavaFX Maven Archetype
    • Pros: Modern UI with JavaFX, interactive, good for desktop apps.
    • Cons: Complex UI design, platform-dependent, higher learning curve.
  5. Simple JavaFX Maven Archetype
    • Pros: Easier setup, good for desktop UIs, faster start.
    • Cons: Limited features, less structured, platform-dependent.
  6. POM Project
    • Pros: Flexible, customizable, modular.
    • Cons: Complex setup, higher learning curve, time-consuming.

Gradle vs. Maven

Gradle:

  • Pros: Flexible, performant, highly customizable, better multi-project support.
  • Cons: Steeper learning curve, more complex build scripts.

Maven:

  • Pros: Easier setup, convention over configuration, large community, reliable.
  • Cons: Less flexible, slower builds, XML can be verbose.

Recommendations for an RSS Feed Reader Application

  • Simple Projects: Use Maven Java Application or Gradle Java Application.
  • Rich UI Desktop: Use FXML JavaFX Maven Archetype or Simple JavaFX Maven Archetype.
  • Web-Based: Use Maven Web Application or Gradle Web Application.
  • Modern and Scalable: Consider Gradle Micronaut Project or Java Frontend Application.
@IdelsTak
Copy link
Author

Maven project types:

netbeans-new-project-dialog-screenshot_2024-07-16_03-14-56

@IdelsTak
Copy link
Author

Gradle project types:

netbeans-gradle-new-project-dialog-screenshot_2024-07-16_03-14-56

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment